The Science of Sodium Bromide
Back in 1981 we introduced the industry to Yellow Treat and a new type of algicide; Sodium Bromide. Now that so many manufacturers are offering their own sodium bromide, we thought we would share the science of how it works, and how to shop for it.

What is sodium bromide?

Sodium Bromide is a white granular salt that is very similar to it’s cousin sodium chloride – or regular salt. And just like it’s cousin, the important bit is the part that comes at the end of name – bromide.

Bromine vs. Chlorine

Bromine is very similar to chlorine. They are both halogens that are very good at sanitizing water. But they do have some key differences between them.

One of the key differences is how they appear in pure form; chlorine is gas and bromine is a much heavier gas, to the point of being almost a liquid.

Periodic Videos | Chlorine and Bromine

Check out these videos to learn more about the elements of chlorine and bromine

In water, they both behave very similarly. Bromine added to water will form Hypobromous acid and Hydrobromic Acid, just like chlorine forms Hypochlorous acid and Hydrochloric acid. And Hypobromous acid also disassociates based on pH to form hypobromite just like hypochlorous acid does to form hypochlorite. Similarly, the “hypo” is considered to be the better form at disinfection.

Chlorine Reactions in Water

Cl2 + H2O → HCl + HOCl

HOCl ← → OCl + H+

%

Hypochlorous Acid @ pH ~ 7.5

Bromine Reactions in Water

Br2 + H2O → HBr + HOBr

HOBr ← → OBr + H+

%

Hypobromous Acid @ pH ~ 7.5

However, bromine differs in one key way – and that’s how much hypobromous acid is present based on pH.

At a pH of around 7.5 you’ll have about 50/50 hypochlorous acid vs hypochlorite. But at the same pH, you’d get 80% hypobromous acid! This carries across the pH range where you have significantly more “active” bromine versus what you’d get using chlorine.

Using Bromine with Chlorine

The real action happens when you use BOTH bromine and chlorine, such as with algaecides.

BromoChloride

Initially when bromine and chlorine interact they form certain amounts of BromoChloride. This is both an extremely powerful oxidizer and extremely unstable. It’s instability causes it to break down very quickly.

Displacement

Chlorine is more reactive than bromine. When sodium bromide is added to the water, the chlorine will displace the bromine – releasing it in its pure form into the water.

2NaBr + Cl2 (aq) → 2NaCl + Br2

Because chlorine has a stronger desire for the electron of bromine, the chlorine oxidizes the bromide to form bromine and is reduced from chlorine to chloride.

The Bromine then forms hypobromous acid in the water. Any chlorine added in excess of dissolved sodium bromide will function as normal, forming hypochlorous acid. The result is getting two forms of sanitation working simultaneously!

This is an oversimplification of the chemistry happening in the pool, but explains the basic concept. 

Burn Off

While Bromine can’t be stabilized like chlorine, Bromine on average burns off slower than unstabilized chlorine. This is due to it being closer to a liquid at normal temperature and pressures than chlorine. So in the absence of stabilizer, chlorine will tend to burn off more quickly. 

U

Fact-Check: Converting to a Bromine Pool

Some manufacturers claim that sodium bromide will “convert” the pool into a bromine pool, and usually use this as an argument against Sodium Bromide based algaecides. 

Idea of “Conversion”

In general terms we think of converting a pool meaning changing it from one type of sanitizer to another. If you want a hydrogen peroxide pool, you may have to convert it from chlorine. And vice versa. The idea is discontinuing the use of one sanitizer for another, because they are incompatible.

However, there is no such thing as “converting” a pool from bromine to chlorine, or vice versa. Yes, the pool is producing bromine via reaction with chlorine. But there’s nothing to preclude the use of one with the other.  What determines whether one pool is chlorine based versus another that’s bromine based is simply which one you add more of. If you add more chlorine than bromine to the water, then it’s a chlorine pool. If you add more bromine than chlorine, it’s a bromine pool.

Another statement competitors make is that “once a bromine pool, always a bromine pool”. This is chemically inaccurate. While bromine has some more longevity in the water when compared to unstabilized chlorine, it definitely burns off with heat and sunlight. Otherwise, you would only have to add bromine once to the pool forever. If that were the case, all pools would be bromine pools. Imagine how cost effective that would be!

Drawbacks of Sodium Bromide

While Sodium Bromide is a powerful weapon in the fight against algae, it’s not perfect. And there’s one issue you may run into – getting an accurate chlorine reading.

Chlorine Readings

Occasionally when using Sodium Bromide, you may notice that it’s difficult to obtain a chlorine reading. There’s a few reasons for this:

  1. Some of the chlorine is being used to produce bromine: A portion of the chlorine added to the water is being reduced to chloride, which doesn’t react the same to the reagent in tests
  2. Chlorine will burn off more quickly: the bromine in the water doesn’t burn off as quickly as the chlorine may. In this case, the zero chlorine reading is not necessarily inaccurate, just reflecting the fact that chlorine is burning quickly.
  3. The reagent you’re using may not be having the appropriate reaction: Depending on the test you use, the reagent may be reacting to bromine even when following directions for a chlorine test. This is most typical for DPD tests, where there’s different procedures for testing either amounts. Remember that both chlorine and bromine behave similarly.

How to avoid Chlorine Testing Problems

There are few simple things you can do to prevent chlorine reading issues when using Sodium Bromide:

Don’t overdose

With sodium bromide, more is not better. Instead, focus on the ratio of sodium bromide to chlorine. Luckily this ratio is pretty easy to figure out with a little bit of chemistry.

Pure Sodium Bromide has 77.6% bromide by weight. So 1 pound of sodium bromide has approximately 12 ounces of bromide. So how much chlorine do you need to add to convert all the bromide to bromine?

Let’s start with chlorine gas (Cl2). Chlorine gas is 100% available chlorine. We need one chlorine atom for every bromine atom. Each chlorine molecule has 2 chlorine atoms. So we need about half the weight of chlorine gas for the weight of bromine – or 6 ounces.

Now that we know that, we can use available chlorine percentages to calculate how much you’d need of anything else:

  • Sodium Hypochlorite (12% AC): 50 ounces by weight. A gallon roughly weighs 10lbs. (160 ounces). Therefore, you need to add about a third of a gallon.
  • Sodium Dichlor (56% AC): 11 ounces
  • Calcium Hypochlorite (70% AC): 9 ounces

Anything added in excess of this will yield a chlorine reading.

Typical directions for using Sodium Bromide are 5 ounces per 10,000 gallons. Assuming you’re shocking with at least a pound or gallon of chlorine per 10,000 gallons, you’d be adding about 4 times more chlorine than bromide to the water.

Use an OTO test

If you still run into problems with getting a reading using your DPD test or strips, use an OTO test. Technically OTO is for total chlorine, but since the bromine is reducing the chlorine, you can use it to assess chlorine levels and treat it like it’s free chlorine.

Since the bromine may still slow down the reading, you should let it sit for 5-10 minutes.

Getting the Most out of Sodium Bromide

So now that you understand the science behind sodium bromide based algaecides, now the question becomes which do you buy?

It’s worth noting that some companies (like ours) add other ingredients to improve the efficacy of the algaecide. This is why you’ll often see lower percentages of sodium bromide on our products; we add other things to make it work better.

Most Sodium Bromide products claim an active ingredient level of 98-99%. None of these products have more than one ingredient or are patented for use as an algicide like Yellow Treat, Swamp Treat or No Mor Problems. If you pick up one bottle that is 99% from one company, and another that says 99% from another, odds are they both bought it from the same chemical manufacturer and slapped their name on it.

If you can open and look inside the bottle, you should see a white granules. If the product looks off white or has a strong smell, it might have organic contaminants and should be avoided.

What’s the strongest?

Some manufacturers will tell you that their product is stronger by virtue of a higher percentage.

In the case of a generic sodium bromide salt, that’s largely true. A 99% is stronger than 98% (although it’s arguable if it is at all noticeable).

However, that doesn’t carry over to formulated products. For example, our strongest algaecide Swamp Treat™ has one of the lowest percentages of Sodium Bromide (67.6%).

%

Sodium Bromide

In the end it comes down to cost vs. benefit. When you look at formulated products like ours, they will indeed work better because of other ingredients added to the mix and the quality of source chemical. If you’re looking for something “good enough” and cheap – just price out the cheapest generic 98-99% you can find.

Read More

Does Column Pouring Acid Really Work?

When you service pools, you’re constantly looking for tricks and hacks to save time and money. One trick that’s circulating among pool professionals is “column” pouring to save on time and balancers. Here we pick apart the claim with the science to determine if it’s real or just a poolguy fairy tail.

Do phosphates levels matter?

There is debate in the industry regarding how important phosphate levels are in pools. One side says using phosphate removers is an integral part of maintaining an algae free pool, while the other says it’s a total waste of money. In this article we break down the science to give you an answer.

What is Plaster Spot Etching or Soft Spots?

There’s an ongoing debate on the nature of white spots forming on plaster. One side claims that it is due to the balancing of the water chemistry. The other, that it’s from poor craftsmanship when installing plaster. Here we analyze the argument and the science behind plaster spots.

What really causes Pool Plaster Etching

In our post about spot etching we talked about this concept of “aggressive water”. While we don’t necessarily like the term (it should be corrosive not aggressive), it’s widespread enough to warrant discussion. In this article we go over the chemistry behind plaster etching, and how to avoid it.

The Science of Sodium Bromide

Back in 1981 we introduced the industry to Yellow Treat and a new type of algicide; Sodium Bromide. Now that so many manufacturers are offering their own sodium bromide, we thought we would share the science of how it works, and how to shop for it.

The Pool Chemistry of Cyanuric Acid

Is Cyanuric acid both a blessing and a curse? It helps stabilize chlorine so it burns more slowly, but too much is thought to reduce the efficacy of your sanitizer. Or does it? Here we break down the science behind one of the most misunderstood chemical compounds in swimming pools.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *